Yet, on the other hand, the implicit danger if you pick and choose is that you may do great dishonor to the person or system if you do not do so carefully. You may even end up using them to support something that they never would have supported in a thousand years. One example is a philosophy professor I had who tried to teach that Augustine was a universalist and a socialist.
So how do you do this carefully? I have found that it is helpful to outline methodological differences you may have with the other party that will explain why you end up at different conclusions than they do and methodological similarities that may explain why you agree with them. For example, I recently argued in a paper that Evangelicals must rewrite Bonhoeffer's Life Together because it is a valuable work but it is written from the perspective of Neo-Orthodox Theologian, and Evangelicals of necessity have a different interpretive method.
All this foreplay is to introduce a brief sketch of some of the methodological similarities and differences that I have and some conclusions with one of my great theological heroes, John Calvin. John Calvin was a second generation Reformer in the city of Geneva who spent much of his life doing the duty which he likened to Jonah being sent to the Ninevites. He was a brilliant man who had a great amount of influence upon the Christianity which followed. His followers have elaborated on his beliefs, and the traditions that have come out of him have formed the backbone of Evangelical Christianity for centuries.
While these are not the only similarities I share with Calvin, these are some of the major ones:
1) A Biblical Theologian: First and foremost Calvin was a Biblical Theologian in the tradition of the Reformation message of Sola Scriptura. Most major commentaries still quote his set of commentaries. Despite his differences, N.T. Wright admits in Justification that when he was first learning of Luther and Calvin he knew if nothing else he must have the same method as them. Calvin was essentially exegetical. His first priority was to the text.
2) Confessionally Orthodox: Calvin was confessionally Orthodox. The initial purpose of his massive Institutes, the first Reformation Systematic Theology, was to convince the King of France that Protestantism, while different than the native Catholocism, was a viable form of Orthodox Christianity. In fact in every edition of The Institutes while he was alive he included a copy of the original letter to King Francis. Calvin held to the Apostles' Creed, exhaled quotes from the church Fathers, and denounced heretics who departed from the traditional teachings of the church.
3) A Committed Protestant: Before coming to Geneva, Calvin lived in hiding in France for his belief which he developed (if memory serves correctly) at the University of Paris. He spent time in Strasbourg after his initial stint in Geneva learning from Martin Bucer (one of the least known but most formative members of the initial Reformers). Calvin was committed to each of the five Solas of the Reformation: Sola Fide, Sola Gratia, Soli Deo Gloria, Sola Scriptura, Solus Christus. Melancthon, Luther, Bucer, and Zwingli were among his contacts and his "co-laborers."
4) The Sovereignty and Glory of God: This is perhaps the most famous and controversial aspect of Calvin's theology. While there is argumentation over whether or not Calvin would be a Calvinist soteriologically, I believe that the 5 points of Calvinism do an accurate job portraying Calvin's views. Furthermore, I am absolutely in accord with him on this (although, I do believe "L" and "P" respectively deserve a little more treatment than most give). I believe more important to Calvin, though, was a system of theology that was framed overall around the sovereignty of God. For Calvin, the world was in the hands of an omniscient, omnipresent, and omnipotent Creator who willed what he must for his purposes. We are greatly indebted to him.
5) Salvation through Union with Christ: Finally, Calvin's insight into Soteriology extends far beyond the 5 points. For Calvin, Salvation through Christ alone was Christ alone. All the benefits of salvation are rooted in the mysterious Union with Christ. Imputation, Adoption, Perseverance, Sanctification, these are all results of Union with Christ. Calvin's Union with Christ has become something of a "common ground" for Theologians of various stripes.
Despite the respect I have for Calvin, I distinguish myself in the following areas:
1) A "Christocentric" Hermeneutic: I believe that a much better descriptor of the relationship of all of Scripture to Christ is "Christotelic" that all of Scripture finds its "end" in Christ. While Calvin believed in a highly typological reading of Scripture, termed "Christocentric," I believe that Christotelic is a much better descriptor.
2) Prophet, Priest, King; Moral, Ceremonial, Civil (or Judicial): For Calvin, Jesus Christ fulfilled three offices, the "prophet, priest, and king." He further divided all of Scripture into "Moral, Ceremonial, and Civil" categories. I think there is some truth in the first distinction. But i find problem with it, it is an arbitrary way to divide up the passages speaking of Christ. Therefore, I find a much more helpful way to understand it is that Christ had one "office," that of Messiah. This office had many facets, prophet, priest, king, shepherd, servant, etc.. Therefore, I see no need to find a parallel division of Scripture as Calvin did.
3) The relationship of Israel and the Church: For Calvin, there is a close relationship of the Church and Israel. The Church is the new Israel. While this is a view held by many that I respect and love, I am a committed Dispensationalist because of my commitment to being a Biblical Theologian. I do not see this "continuity" between Israel and the Church. I believe they are different institutions with different roles in the singular plan of God. I see this as an accurate conclusion of my theology concerning the sovereignty of God. For me then, I do not see a need for Infant Baptism as a sign of the new circumcision.
In conclusion, Calvin is a highly commendable exegete and theologian worthy of due honor. No Pastor or Theologian should ever preach a sermon without perusing the Institutes or looking at his commentaries. We are deeply indebted to him and a lot more "calvinists" should read over what Calvin actually said to get a handle on Scriptures. However, because of my disagreements with the tradition, especially the question of the Church and Israel, my reformed friends tell me I am not actually a Calvinist. While few use this nomenclature officially (although it seems to be a common usage), I would therefore call myself Calvinist but not Reformed. I am committed to Biblical Theology for the Church, I am Confessionally Orthodox, I am a Committed Protestant, I am a "5 pointer" and believe in the complete sovereignty of God, and Union with Christ is the way I understand salvation. However, I do not hold to a Christocentric Hermeneutic, the Prophet, Priest, King division, or that the Israel is succeeded by the church in the plan of God.
Calvin, once again, is one of my heroes, and I have the utmost respect for him. In fact, I think that it would be proper to close thus:
"For... all that He possesses is nothing to us until we grow into one body with Him." - Calvin, Institutes
No comments:
Post a Comment