Wednesday, June 5, 2013

Doubt and Damnation: Toward a Biblical Theology of Doubt

I have now come through twenty-three years of informal and formal Christian education. Upon this road with various turns and twists, with highs and lows, mountains and valleys, rocky paths and six-lane highways, I have been inundated with a suspect presupposition. So imbedded and seductive it is, I have heard youth pastors, pastors, teachers, friends, and mentors (all of whom I respect, well, most of whom I respect) proclaim something similar.

This presupposition goes something like this, "All faith must come out of doubt, therefore, doubt is a good thing."


Of course, this was the methodology of the infamous Love Wins by Rob Bell, where he went about to question the Orthodox historical Christian teaching on Hell. (1) Forgive me for my lack of Hegelian Historical knowledge, but I believe that this smacks of a Cartesian dialectic. Not to discredit this man who is much brighter than I, but I would submit that this is a damnable presupposition. (2)


How can I say doubt is damnable?


First, (as a friend pointed out) it is necessary to define doubt. I believe doubt can be understood (as will be demonstrated further by the following), as putting yourself in the place to judge the existence of God as he has revealed himself or the ability of God to make good on his promises.
  Let's briefly look at most of the following New Testament passages on doubt:

Matthew 21:21-22 :: And Jesus answered them, "Truly, I say to you, if you have faith and do not doubt, you will not only do what has been done to the fig tree, but even if you say to this mountain, 'Be taken up and thrown into the sea,' it will happen. And whatever you ask in prayer, you will receive, if you have faith."


Mark 11:23 :: Truly, I say to you, whoever says to this mountain, 'Be taken up and thrown into the sea,' and does not doubt in his heart, but believes that what he says will come to pass, it will be done for him.


In Matt 21:20-22 and Mark 11:20-26, Jesus and his disciples are walking past the fig tree that Jesus had commanded to be shriveled. His disciples are astonished at the withered form of the plant they had just seen yesterday. Jesus answers their astonishment with the above statement. Without dealing with the nuances of these passages and their various applications in terms of the "Signs and Wonders Movement," (3) allow me to submit three observations on what they say about doubt. 1- Doubt is the opposite of faith. 2- God will honor the prayer, but only if the one praying has faith, and consequently, does not doubt. 3- In Mark 11:25, Jesus includes a statement on forgiveness by faith. What is remarkable here is that forgiveness does not happen out of doubt but out of faith.


Acts 10:20 :: Rise and go down and accompany them without hesitation, for I have sent them.


This is a command from Jesus telling Peter to go "without hesitation" but is actually the same word (diakrino) used for doubt. One simple observation about doubt here: Obedience without doubt is what is demanded from us.


Romans 4:20-21 :: No unbelief made him waver concerning the promise of God, but he grew strong in his faith as he gave glory to God, fully convinced that God was able to do what he had promised.


This classic chapter is speaking of Abraham's faith in God as an example for us. Here wavering is the same word as doubting (diakrino), and used in the same way. Here are some observations on doubt from Romans 4:20-21: 1- Unbelief produces doubt. 2- Doubt, biblically, is unbelief in God being able to do what he says he will do. 3- Faith is once again the opposite of doubt here.


Romans 14:23 :: But whoever has doubts is condemned if he eats, because the eating is not from faith. For whatever does not proceed from faith is sin.


What is interesting is that Romans as a situational letter is meant to unite Jews and Gentiles under their common savior and salvation. 14 is one of the chapters that really is the result of this long sustained argument. Let me offer two things I can observe: 1- Faith and doubt are once again polarized. 2- Doing something out of doubt is perceived as sin.


James 1:6-8 :: But let him ask in faith, with no doubting, for the one who doubts is like a wave of the sea that is driven and tossed by the wind. For that person must not suppose that he will receive anything from the Lord; he is a double-minded man, unstable in all his ways.


 In James 1:2-8, James has already remarked that faith + trials = perseverance (and its fruits). James then remarks that if anyone lacks wisdom to ask from God. Now, here are some observations about doubt from this passage: 1- Doubt is the opposite of faith. 2- Doubters are like a sea (constant in movement) tossed about by the wind. 3- Doubters cannot depend on anything from the Lord 4- They are double-minded and unstable. 5- God will not honor prayers from doubters for wisdom.


Jude 1:22-23 :: 22 And have mercy on those who doubt; 23 save others by snatching them out of the fire; to others show mercy with fear, hating even the garment stained by the flesh.


With these verses, vs. 22 and 23 qualify eachother. Here are some observations on doubt here. 1- Jude commands us to have mercy on doubters. 2- You have mercy on doubters by rescuing them from hell, presumably by preaching the gospel.


Let's compile some of these observations 1- Doubt is a product of unbelief. 2- Doubt is the opposite of faith. 3- God will not honor prayers out of doubt whether for forgiveness, wisdom, or anything else. 4- Obedience does not doubt. 5- Doing things out of doubt is sin. 6- Doubters are unstable. 7- Doubters must be rescued from hellfire.


Now, let me add a qualifier. I left out one rather significant observation. Doubt always requires an object, and in almost all of these passages (4) the object of doubt is Jesus the Christ, the son of God and what he has said he is going to do. Therefore, everything concerning what he has explicitly said he is going to do or who he is is not up for doubting. However, be careful concerning your ability to interpret what things you have felt promised by God that are temporal (a new car, a new baby, a new girlfriend, an old girlfriend, etc.), be very careful whenever you feel that God is in your debt!


Now, I am very interested in James' assertion that doubters are double minded because I find it incredibly relevant to our discussion on doubt. The word for doubt in the new testament, is a variation on the word for judging. Now while being careful to avoid any exegetical fallacies, I would propose that there is a connection to one who doubts something and judging. I think James' assertion is so telling because the one who doubts is unstable, in other words he believes that he is God's judge. How ironic that he does not see that he has nothing to stand on himself! No rock to cling to. He is in no position to judge God, he is like the waves being tossed about.


Now I do not deny the existence of doubt in the believer anymore than I would deny the existence of self-righteousness, sexual immorality, thievery, lust, greed, licentiousness, anger, bitterness, or pride present in unbelievers and believers alike. Like any other sin, I would exhort and encourage all to repent! Lord help us that we do doubt. 


To those who would encourage some to doubt in order to come to a firmer resolve upon the nature of God, shame on you. That is like telling a man in a building burning not to call 911 until he is really sure that the firetrucks will come. He will see the firetrucks come to save his soul after he has trusted the 911 operator enough to call him! Here we firmly concur with our brother Anselm, 'I do not understand in order to believe, but rather I believe in order to understand.'

"Pastors" who encourage doubt are harbingers of hellfire. The Bible has no room for doubt, because the one who doubts puts himself in a position to judge God. The one who has put himself in a position to judge God is like the idolater who knows which end of the log to worship and the other with which to cook a steak. He has misinterpreted himself as one who can rightly determine the actions of the divine Almighty. What an arrogant position to take?! How do your backs not break, as you a finite creature judges the infinite without error? What amazement.


Somewhat ironically to their arrogant postulate, doubters will often claim that those who unreservedly have faith are arrogant for thinking they have it all pieced together. But on the contrary having faith is not claiming to understand everything, but claiming to understand that we as fallen finite creatures cannot understand the infinite. 


The command in the Bible is not to "doubt" then to come to belief. The command in the Bible is to believe on the Lord Jesus Christ for forgiveness of sins. Do not encourage doubt! Rather command humble belief. Rip the scales off of the eyes of sinners, reveal how wretched and naked, how in need of a savior they are, and then give them the water which will never allow them to thirst again.


"I do not understand Lord, I do not comprehend how you can be three and one, omniscient, omnipotent, omnipresent, immanent and transcendent, how Jesus is God and man, two natures one person. But I do believe. Oh Lord, we believe, help our unbelief!"


Francis Schaefer said this of his day that deserves application in our own, "Our generation needs to be told that man cannot disregard God, that a culture like ours that has had such light and then has deliberately turned away stands under God's judgment. God is a God of grace, but the other side of the coin of grace is judgment. If God is there, if God is holy, (and we need a holy God or we have no absolutes), there must be judgment.... There is only one kind of preaching that will do in a generation like ours - preaching which includes the preaching of the judgment of God." (5)


I beg you with Jude, "Have mercy on doubters." Preach the Gospel. Maranatha.


____________________________________________________

1 - I do not have time (or patience) to address Love Wins here. To see a passionate, verbose, well thought out response, see Dr. McDuffee's excellent treatment: http://mcduffee.wordpress.com/2011/03/23/love-covers-a-multitude-of-sin-but-conquers-no-one/
2 - The title to this piece, "Doubt and Damnation: Toward a Biblical Theology of Doubt" is titled so because this does not bear all the marks of a true Biblical theology. I say this because, it is not framed in terms of progressive revelation. Also, it is put together in a rather haphazard manner with little research done in secondary sources. However, I hope that the following remarks may be helpful to anyone wishing to further the task.
3 - Most Evangelical scholars would say that the tree that withered is a physical parable Jesus gives the disciples of the nation of Israel, playing on Old Testament allusions and references to Israel as a vine. For example, Isaiah 5:1-7. The mountain being thrown into the sea here is in my opinion mount Zion, where Jerusalem was built on. How were the disciples able to do these things through faith? The puritans had an old saying, "The same sun that melts the ice bakes the clay." One of the effects of proclaiming the gospel is the hardening of hearts and issuing of people into damnation. Some people receive it, out of faith, some people reject it out of doubt. The Mark 11 passage is particularly powerful because the force of what Jesus is saying is that out of the power of faith one can forgive.
4 - The exception would be Romans 14, but I would argue that 14, in an ultimate way, is talking about doubting Jesus as the Christ, the son of David and all the theology that precedes it in the first 13 chapters.
5 - Francis Schaeffer, Death in the City (Downer's Grove: InterVarsity Press, 1969) 44-45.

2 comments:

  1. Thanks Matt! I think we all struggle on some level with this very thing. I believe you could spend some more time developing what doubt actually is. There is a difference between doubt and seeking truth when we don't know where God stands on a matter. At first I started to come to the conclusion that you were claiming that we are not to wrestle with the big questions but have have faith. I would have to say that we all need to wrestle through the big questions so that we can stand firmly with God in faith.

    Two verses come to mind when I think about this.
    Mark 9:24
    24 Immediately the boy’s father exclaimed, “I do believe; help me overcome my unbelief!”

    I believe this man is dead on. We are to lean on our faith and in the middle of that, understand that we are still in need of more faith and knowledge of who God is. Who better to go to than the author?

    Malachi 3:10
    Bring the whole tithe into the storehouse, that there may be food in my house. Test me in this,” says the Lord Almighty, “and see if I will not throw open the floodgates of heaven and pour out so much blessing that there will not be room enough to store it.

    Again here I believe we are to have more than fluffy faith but strong faith that has been put to the test.

    Maybe separating a doubter from a truth seeker(wish I had a better word). I despise the word seeker because of what it has done to so many of God's fellowships but that is something for another time I am sure.
    love you and miss you,
    jared shelton
    p.s. call me some time when you have a chance 6303100588

    ReplyDelete
  2. Hi Jared,

    Thanks for the comment, it has allowed me to develop this a little further. To your first suggestion to spend more time developing what doubt actually is. I apologize, I thought that was clear, but then again, I did write the blog late at night. I would define doubt, biblically, as putting yourself in the place to judge the existence of God as he has revealed himself or the ability of God to make good on his promises. I believe this is the stand that the Bible takes.

    As for the distinction between “truth seekers” and “doubters,” I believe that Scriptures are very clear, there aren’t really “truth seekers.” Now without going into the lengthy excursis between Calvinism and Arminianism (I’ll spoil it for the readers: The Calvinists got this one right), let me qualify. There are absolutely people who are looking for the truth, but they are still “doubters” in the sense that they have put themselves in a position to judge the existence of God as he has revealed himself or his ability to make good on his promises. In other words, there's not really a distinction in terms of how they approach God. The only way into relationship with the Almighty is by coming to a realization of how unable to judge God you are.

    I would say that Malachi 3:10 actually supports my thesis. God is commenting on how the tithes of the Israelites in the storehouse were lacking. God says that if they bring the full tithe they will be blessed. This is the Old Testament covenant; it is not a new promise. If the Israelites obeyed the covenant, they would be blessed. God is calling them to test him by doing what they were actually covenanted to do in the first place. In other words, they needed to have faith in the God who gave them the covenant in the first place.

    Mark 9:24 also supports my thesis. The boy’s father simultaneously claims belief and unbelief. But he does not say, well I have both. No! He exclaims, “I believe, help my unbelief!” He says he has both unbelief and belief. But what the man understood that many do not is that doubt is not ideal, doubt is not a good starting place, doubt is unbelief and sin and must be fled like a burning building.

    You will find the following (as well as the definition of doubt above) edited into the blog post above:
    “Now I do not deny the existence of doubt in the believer anymore than I would deny the existence of self-righteousness, sexual immorality, thievery, lust, greed, licentiousness, anger, bitterness, or pride present in unbelievers and believers alike. Like any other sin, I would exhort and encourage all to repent! Lord help us that we do doubt.

    “To those who would encourage some to doubt in order to come to a firmer resolve upon the nature of God, shame on you. That is like telling a man in a building burning not to call 911 until he is really sure that the firetrucks will come. He will see the firetrucks come to save his soul after he has trusted the 911 operator enough to call him! Here we firmly concur with our brother Anselm, 'I do not understand in order to believe, but rather I believe in order to understand.'”

    ReplyDelete