Truth not Idealism from Arcane Productions on Vimeo.
A guy on my floor made this video a while ago. It really codifies alot of what I've been thinking about lately. In his book "Fame is Infamy" Andrew Schwab confronts a problem in modern America, a problem that all of us are guilty of. We are all guilty of setting fame in other's eyes as an ideal to reach for. We are guilty of having an idealistic pedestal that others should step onto. We all feel like there is this inner knowledge of a distant ideal that we should aspire to. We all feel like there is a human ideal that we should pursue.
Is this wrong?
I had a girl recently tell me that between 30 % - 50 % of all her girl friends growing up admitted to having some kind of eating disorder or body self-image issue eventually. When I asked why, she shrugged and said it's because they wanted to feel like they were beautiful.
The stats are in. Around 80% of American males have had some kind of continuing pornographic contact. When asked why, the guys say that it's completely normal. It's what boys do. Analytical minds would contend that it's because the males want to feel powerful because they can control "beautiful" girls.
In the 1930's and 40's, Hitler and his followers exterminated some 4 million people: Jews, Gypsies, Jehovah's Witnesses, and Homosexuals from the face of the planet because they were were pollutants to the "perfect" races in Europe. Before that Hitler and his followers performed "mercy" killings on autistic and mentally challenged children and adults because they weren't fitting of the perfect human condition.
Before that, almost all of Western Civilization controlled humans because they were lesser human beings. Slaveowners actually argued that they were being merciful to the slaves by taking them out of their homelands and forcing them to work on plantations because their idea of civilization was so much better.
In the Bible, James and the Judaizers came to Antioch trying to force circumcision on the Christians because all Christianity must conform to their ideal. Paul alone stood against them when Peter wavered. They eventually backed down. Needless to say, there were sighs of relief going on throughout Antioch from the male Gentile population there.
A pastor friend of mine told me a story about somebody who was called into the ministry in an elderly congregation. He tried to force his modern viewpoints on the congregation, and within a year, three of the original families were still there, and the church was on it's way out.
This pinnacle of idealism we are trying to reach doesn't exist. It's dangerous and harmful. it's what modern culture is built on. The false concept of beauty, this success we are encouraged to reach for is a peak of unstable ground. What's worse? In many ways that is what the American church is founded on. Where does this unsteady foundation come from?
The origins of Western Idealism, while it didn't originate with him are much founded by Plato. Plato was the student of famous teacher Socrates. While Socrates challenged the Sophists ( the ancient equivelant of postmodernism), Plato attributed to his teacher Socrates a deadly lie. The deadly lie of the forms, that is that there is an ideal for everything and that we should try to achieve the one idea are really not that far off from the thinking of the Sophist Protagaros who famously said "Man is the measure of all things" Sure there are minute differences, but in the seed of Platonic Form, this idea has infiltrated the church all the way until modern times. Admittedly Plato was trying to establish an absolute system to refute the Sophists, but he went too far.
Don't get me wrong. I am an absolutist in the vein of Aristotle. I agree whole heartedly with this pagan philosopher's statement, repeated by Ayn Rand (Atheist Author) and every single sunday school teacher I ever had, "To say there are no absolutes is in itself, an absolute statement." There is a truth, and we can know Him. And better than that, that same Truth can set us free. All the pain, hurt, cutting, eating disorder, pornography, alcoholism, drug use, idolatry, adultery, lust, violence, abuse, worship disorders, and every other damage we've inflicted on ourselves, we can in fact be set free from. Furthermore I believe that this is the ONLY way we can be set free. Our sins are alone paid for by Christ, nobody can approach the Father except through Him.This is the truth that I will affirm, fight, and if necessary, die for.
But let's be honest as well. There is no ideal standard that we can hold others to on many things. This is going to be controversial, but as I've said before, the Book of Romans very clearly makes the statement that God convicts different people of different things. We all have different gifts. I had a friend of mine point out that Mark Driscoll, one of the most "successful" pastors in America wouldn't have the same affect outside of Seattle, but God has perfectly tailored him for that job. God convicts different people differently and He gifts different people differently.
I was explaining this to a new Christian the other day that God convicts different people differently. He was complaining about a certain friend's behavior and I had to explain to him that often times God is working on a person's characteristics that we don't see and so when we slam a brother to not holding up our ideal, we could be discouraging our brother and in case you didn't realize, we are told to encourage our brothers probably just as much as they are told to stop sinful behavior. Your ideal might be wrong to them as well. I of all people acknowledge that sometimes brothers need to be confronted but too often we are guilty of accusing and not listening to try to help them work through problems.
Another problem I've noticed is that we as Christians are good at demanding other Christians live holy lives. But we are terrible at discipling them. What if somebody doesn't know what a Godly life looks like? Instead of questioning their salvation, maybe we should get out of the command center and lead them on the front lines. If you spend any time in ministry you'll realize that there is a desperate need for people to stop pointing fingers and to lend a helping hand. And instead of making cookie cutter Christians, what if we let them have a walk that is specifically tailored to the way that God has designed them?
That's why people struggle so much with many of their addictions. They're afraid of the shame they somewhat correctly know we'll lay on them. So they waste away in their own little pit where nobody is reaching to them. If you've ever met anybody who struggled with Pornography or Eating Disorders, and I'm almost 100% sure that you have, then you know that what they need isn't an accusation. They're already convicted. They need help.
One example is spiritual disciplines. I have met people who do their quiet time by spending three or four hours in commentary and Biblical passage. I have met people who do their quiet times by reading the Pilgrim's Progress. Others do their quiet times in Augustine's Confessions. Others spend their quiet times in the Word alone. Other's spend their quiet times by listening to worship music, some to metal. Who are you to judge how somebody does their relationship with God? Sometimes I get more out of walking to class listening to my ipod and Christian artists like As I Lay Dying and Project 86 than I do listening to chapel for hours. I honestly can sometimes worship in song by humming along to Christian metal more than I get on Sunday Morning Worship at church.
And I know that starts almost a spiritual gag reflex. Because it is so contrary to what we've been taught in our churches. Here's the deal, if they're not a Christian, God will meet them at that level when and how we want to. And if they are a Christian, God will convict them how He needs to, and draw them to Him. That's his job. Our job is to be what God has made us to be. Feel free to share your convictions in a loving matter, especially when you think your brother is in sin, but be careful that you do not discourage him.
Take it from somebody who has learned that lesson the hard way, more often than not you're the one in the wrong. Share the truth with them lovingly and lovingly share why you think it's the truth. Especially if God has gifted you as a teacher and put it on your conscience to talk to them. But, let's be honest, a large majority of the time when somebody's walk bothers us it is because we are annoyed they're not living like we are trying to be, and they have no clue that Christ is waiting for us to love them. Often times this gag reflex is a pride problem. God will lead them where He wants them to be, and He calls us to help them get there by building love and relationship. God doesn't have a moral ideal for all humans. My struggles, while similar, are different than yours. I live in an entirely different context than you. Trying to force my convictions on you, especially when God is convicting you in a different way than me, usually doesn't work, especially when I haven't examined my own problems first.
It was with this in mind when Jesus chided the Jews in his Sermon on the Mount, "Why do you look at the speck in your brother's eye but don't notice the log in your own eye? Or how can you say to your brother, 'Let me take the speck out of your eye,' and look, there's a log in your eye? Hypocrite! First take the log out of your eye, and then you will see clearly to take the speck out of your brother's eye." (Matthew 7:3-5)
I exhort you brothers and sisters, abandon Idealism and pursue Freedom.
No comments:
Post a Comment