Thursday, November 8, 2012

Why Be Part of the Local Church?

Last night in my Systematic Theology class we talked about the distinction between the visible and the invisible church. The visible church are all those who go to church, who call themselves Christians, and the invisible church are the universal church and all those who are truly Christians, that is they have put a personal trust in Christ as their savior.

This inherently raises a question, why should Christians join a local church if they are part of the invisible church?

Before we can address the situation, we must define being part of a local church. There are 3 Protestant distinctives to what makes up a local church: Preaching of the Word, Administration of the Lord's Supper and Baptism, and Church discipline. How do you be "part of the local church" then? I believe that you are "part of the local church" when you have submitted yourself to the spiritual authority of the elders and have committed yourself spiritually to the fellowship of that body.

While I believe there are probably dozens of Biblical considerations, let me give 3 of the more compelling reasons:

1 - The purpose of the church is the maturity of the saints into the image of Christ. (Ephesians 4:1-16)

When I teach through this passage, I generally start with this situation. Imagine you are meeting your girlfriend or boyfriend's (or spouse's!) parents for the first time. You walk into the house and you all shake hands and have a good time. Things seem to be off on the right foot. Then you ask their mother what is for dinner. Non-candidly they reply breast milk. You are puzzled, and you ask why breast milk. And the mother says that she never really could get around to weaning the person you are interested in, and didn't see them acting their age as important.

I believe a Christian who is not part of a local church and sees no importance to it as described above is analogous to a person who wants to sip on breast milk for the rest of their life. Now I know that seems extreme, but if the God-given way for him to bring maturity into your life is the church, then you, in an unbelievably arrogant position, have said you don't need his divine means of bringing maturity into your life.

Now some of you may have gone and read the passage and acutely observed that the above passages seem to be talking about the universal church. And I would agree, as expressed in the local church. Without getting into all the nitty-gritty of the passage, such space is not allowed here, let me give you two observations. Look at vs. 11-12. First, where do any of the apostles go without setting up churches? If not explicitly mentioned, churches being planted always follow them. When there is already a church there, the first place the apostles go is to the church there. Secondly the shepherd has no purpose if he has no flock to shepherd. For the good of the sheep, the shepherd will lead the flock where food is, will protect them from danger, and will discipline them.

2 - Without a local church, the instructions about elders and church discipline become untenable.

1 Timothy 3 and Titus 1 both place incredibly high standards for elders. The reason for this? The elders are to guide and provide the teaching of God's word, they are the ones who provide the above 3 marks of the church and they are the ones who are exercise church discipline. Someone who is not held to high standards such as these would certainly abuse the responsibilities that come with being an elder. 1 Timothy 5:17-22 talks about paying honor and gives justification for why paying pastors is legitimate for churches. If you do not assume the context of a local church, that has 2 implications. You are to pay honor to all elders everywhere. Even if they are not at your local church. Even if you don't agree with the doctrine of those churches. Even if those churches do not vet their elders properly. The second implication would mean that you as a Christian are to have part in paying and providing for all those pastors at churches that require payment. You would have to provide for the pastor at third baptist around the corner, otherwise you would be under the discipline of God if he goes hungry. Who appoints the elders if there is no assumed local church? Another elder? Can one elder appoint an elder in another congregation?

Obviously those ideas are ridiculous. The convention of the local church then is what results from all the Biblical teaching.

What about 1 Corinthians 5:12? How can a church purge the evil ones inside of it without an elder base? Do some Christians decide that there is an unrepentant sinner in their midst and expunge him? Could me and my brother excommunicate someone who we met because in our limited position think he is walking in sin? No, that would be meaningless. Do we depend on the word of "mature Christians"? Well obviously not because those mature Christians still have sin nature. And not everybody who knows them would agree. But all those in the fellowship have placed themselves under the leadership of the elders and will so follow the elders as they have agreed to.

3 - It is the assumption of the New Testament that all believers are in a local church.

There is not a book in the New Testament that is not written to a group of Christians in churches. Even Philemon was to read the letter to him to the church that met in his house. Furthermore, there are no references to Christians outside of the church's authority and discipline. That does not mean Campus Crusade for Christ or the Moody Bible Institute. The emphasis of church discipline is on expulsion from your local church's fellowship. Parachurch organizations cannot practice the marks of the church, nor should they!

The local church's discipline is meant to cause the believer to repent. Once the believer has repented then he may reenter the fold and be reconciled to the church. As said above, a believer cannot reasonably be excluded from fellowship and cannot be reconciled to the church apart from the existence of a local church.

Now some of you may have some strong objections, so let me try to address two of the stronger ones that I can anticipate.

1- You don't know what the church did to me.

You're right. But if that argument keeps you from becoming part of a local church, then you have to say everything the local church does is bad. You cannot take the things that you like about the local church be overshadowed by how you may have been hurt. In my experience, most Christians that get frustrated with their churches really like some things about the local church, the teaching, the ordinances, and maybe even the fellowship. But they don't want to submit to authority or church discipline. Over my time at Moody I have been approached three or four times, and even entertained the idea myself, of starting a group of Moody students doing our own thing for church on Sunday morning. My answer to that idea has always been how unbelievably arrogant that is, it is a want of the believer to engage in the things they like about the church but not submit to the local church's authority.

2 - Well I don't agree with my church's position or with the direction they're heading.

Well, if they're heretics, then of course you shouldn't join them. But before you write off an expression of believers, check yourself and the Scriptures. If you're right, they're off, then go find another church. Nowhere is the believer called to fellowship those that go against his conscious to fellowship with. But he is required to submit to a group of believers. Maybe the believer feels called to start their own church. Awesome. But make sure you fit the qualifications of leadership in 1 Timothy 3 and Titus 1 first.

To conclude, I can tell you the times that have challenged me the most, the times I've grown the most, the most life-giving times in my life have been when I was involved in a church. Please, don't be arrogant and think you are the exception to the rule. I know far too many Christians who are unbelievably immature and don't think they need this. But I know plenty of Christians that have put up with far more than I would have from a local church, and still have submitted to the church. My parents have a saying, the smart learn from their own mistakes, but the wise learn from others' mistakes. Don't be the opposite of that wise person, which is a fool.

No comments:

Post a Comment