Thursday, July 19, 2012

The Problem with Piety


"Love God and do as you please." - Augustine

When I was in high school, I used to go to these conferences put on by Christ in Youth with my youth group. I totally love and support these conferences, don't misread what I am saying. But something that would perpetually come up year after year was the American obsession with social media. I remember going to these conferences and being pushed to go on "fasts" of Facebook, email, phones, texts, etc. Not that going on breaks from Social Media is bad, and I think could do a lot of good for a lot of young people, including myself, if they took a break from electronics and spent some real time with God (say once a week, maybe on a Sunday, while they're at church, and with their friends and family, and resting, and basking in the day of the New Creation).

The justification for such encouragement was almost always this verse that Jesus quoted from the Old Testament, "Man does not live by bread alone, but by every word that comes from the mouth of God." (Matthew 4:4, Deut 8:3).

Now what gets subtly taught is that the eating the bread would have been the crime of Jesus. It would have been "cosmic treason" to eat that bread. Jesus had better fast and be pious. So it would then be legitimate for us to withhold things from ourselves so we can become closer to God.

When I go back and look at this, here are two observations I have immediately:

1) Man not by live by bread alone, but man does live by bread. Trust me, try not eating food for an extended period of time. You will rapidly begin to notice you have a lack of strength. You will have no energy. You will be grouchy. Eventually, you will die. Jesus says, that the bread alone is not enough to live by.
2) Jesus is saying this to repel Satan who is offering him bread. You know, the angel Lucifer, who was cast down from heaven for attempting to usurp God's throne, that serpent thing that slithered around the earth and tempted Adam and Eve, was judged by God, the guy who sends his demons and who himself poses as gods to distract man's already wayward affection, who appears in the wilderness to tempt Satan, who is judged at the cross, who Jesus is going to come back with the Saints to destroy, and who eventually ends up burning in the Lake of Fire forever. Yea, that Satan.

So then, man (not just any man either, the God-man, Jesus, who was both God and Man) has a legitimate need for some earthly things that Jesus refuses to allow Satan to fulfill. The problem here would not have been for Jesus to eat bread, but for Jesus to eat bread from Satan, allowing that which is fallen to replace the Almighty as His ultimate provider.

In fact, Paul has some very serious warnings for attempting to become more holy by abstaining from earthly things. If we go look at 1 Timothy 4:1-3a.

Now the Spirit (Holy Spirit, member of the Trinity, proceeds from the Father and the Son, lives His life to glorify both the Son and the Father) expressely (clearly) says that in later times some will depart from the faith by devoting themselves to deceitful spirits and teachings of demons, through the insincerity of liars whose consciences are seared, who forbid marriage and require abstinence from foods that God created...

The entire book of 1 Timothy is devoted to describing to Timothy what a godly ministry looks like. To summarize Chapters 1-3, the church ought to be have incarnationally of the gospel, because it is the buttress and pillar of the truth of the incarnation. So Paul's start in Chapter 4 is pretty clearly dedicated to fighting against some people who would fight against the truth of the incarnation. These people would submit Christians to a gnostic or Judaic way of life. This idea is called asceticism, it is the idea that by abstaining from created things, Christians can become more holy. I have called it above Piety, because this is what passes for devotion to God nowadays.

Let's look at what Paul calls it again. "some will depart from the faith by devoting themselves to deceitful spirits and teachings of demons"
1. It's a departure from the faith, 2. It's devoting yourself to deceitful spirits (WITCHCRAFT) 3. and it's demonic.

Wow Paul. Don't you think you could be a little more gentle?

How do we balance this then? Cause should Christians do Cocaine? Should Christians have premarital sex? Should Christians rob and steal from business?

Obviously not. So how do we balance it?

Let's go back to Jesus. What would have been the crime against the Father?

If Jesus had accepted it from Satan rather than from the Father, that would have been a crime because he would have given Satan that right which God demands. So we take things as God gives them to us. He asks Christians to be sober minded (1 Pet. 1:13) He gives us the gift of sex in marriage (go read Song of Songs for more advice). He tells Christians to do everything they can to live at peace with all men (Romans 12:18) and promises to provide for his children (Matthew 6:25-34)

But what is the key here?

Let's return to 1 Timothy 4:3b-5:

"...Who forbid marriage and require abstinence from foods that God created to be received with thanksgiving by those who believe and know the truth. For everything created by God is good, and nothing is to be rejected if it is received with thanksgiving, for it is made holy by the word of God and prayer."

Paul flips it. He says, don't abstain it, but instead give thanksgiving to God for what you have received. If you praise God for those things which are given by God, then in a sense you are making it holy.

Now one more thing, the implication by this, is that by being ascetic, ultimately you are robbing the glory from God. You could have praised God for what you were given. Instead you chose to deny it in some kind of attempt to prove your devotion. Shame on you. That is damnable, to prove that you can be righteous instead of giving glory to God for it.

Let me show you how this works its way out.

Another thing that gets subtly taught among American singles is that they're told that God will give them someone if they're just content being single. So you have tons of young adults who are afraid to pursue relationship with a guy or girl because they want to prove they're holy and content the way they are right now. They try to mask their real desire (which is lying) by pretending that's not a desire (which is also lying). So they try to fool everybody else and themselves that they really don't need anybody. In the end, they can rob God of glory.

Now, in a sense they should give praise to God because God has provided for them at the moment. But they by no need have to deny they wish to be with someone. That's a God-given, a holy, urge. How do I have a right to say that?

In Genesis, God creates everything, and calls it good. Then he creates man, but does not say it's good. Why? Because man is lonely. Now, if that was something that was impure, God would have created him without that impurity (this was before the Fall). Furthermore, he never would have fulfilled it. But God instead met this legitimate need with a great gift, that ultimately points to the community of the Triune God and the mystery of Christ and the church.

And Adam praised God. I'm assuming that I guess, but there had before been no sin, so I'm sure Adam praised God for the wonderful gift of Eve.

So have a beer, light up a cigar, play some rock'n'roll, fall in love.  Praise God for the gift of beer, the complexity of it's taste. Praise God for the taste of the cigar, the vibrating flavors. Praise God for the way that music and harmony churns your emotions. And praise God for the girl (or the guy). Pray for her. Praise God for her. All the things that she is, the way she makes you smile, that way she makes fun of you for squinting in the sun, and how good at beating you in board games she is. And if she breaks up with you, praise God that he gives and takes away all good gifts. But whatever you do, don't you dare rob the glory from God.

1 comment:

  1. Love this. The questions raised in the beginning are real and felt. A turn to Scripture to dwell in the tension while also finding freedom in truth - and then ending with a paragraph of a life of joy in God and his gifts. Thanks for the thoughts, and writing them down.

    ReplyDelete