To clarify, the question we are trying to answer is: Does God force His love on us?
To make sure we understand, we have to delve into this concept of force. That word has a negative connotation for many people. The way I would define force is if we have a choice whether or not the moment we accept Christ. Make no mistake, the debate is a veiled covering for the argument between a Deterministic Philosophy and the Free Will argument. This debate is as old as Western Civilization itself, and has been a philosophical issue since the days of the great "triptych" of Philosophy, (Socrates, Plato, and Aristotle). This debate in fact has been the main dividing point for Protestant Christianity, the Free Willers on the side of Jacobus Armenius and the Determinists on the side of John Calvin. Today most modern Protestant congregations align themselves leaning towards one side of the debate or other.
There are four main ways to look at this argument.
- Some would take the complete Free Will argument. God loves everybody, but the human race must embrace Christ on an individual basis. Now there are two main problems I see with this argument. First off, God would have to limit Himself and relinquish the fact that He is sovereign. In my opinion, that elevates mankind to a near "godlike" status in the area of salvation by giving man the power to choose. The Free Will argument would state that this is true, but God did in fact limit Himself in some sense, although it is disagreed to what extent, when He became incarnate in Jesus, and no orthodox Christian would disagree with that. Second, they have to deal with a way to explain all the instances in the Bible where God claims complete sovereign power and all the instances where God mentions Predestination in the New Testament. A true Free Willer would say that God looked down the tunnel of time and saw who would pick Him and predestined them. A friend in Arizona explained it to me by saying that God's not a rapist, God doesn't force His love. They would answer, "No, God does not force his love on us, He loves everybody and leaves our choice up to our free will."
- The second opinion is to embrace both sides of the coin. This is by far the most popular view. In my opinion it is because no man who is a result of Western Civilization wants to deny Free Will, but no man who is a Christian wants deny God's sovereignty. While there is little systematic Theology or Philosophy that directly embraces this view, most Theologians or Philosophers who align themselves on one side or the other do not discount this view and actually blend this view with one of the other opinions. In fact there are very few people who would have no tendencies in this way. Even Jonathan Edwards, American Calvinist Hero, could not fully reject the idea of a Free Will, although I'm not sure he would land in this camp. A good friend in Arizona explained his view to me this way, that when we walk through the door of faith, it looks like Free Will. But when we look back it looks like God's Sovereign will. Most of this persuasion would say, "No, God does not force his love on us."
- The third opinion is what I call "Soft Determinism." Soft Determinists would argue that God pursues us until we, the predestined, cannot escape Him any longer. We come to the conclusion that we simply cannot reject God any longer. Therefore we accept Christ. The afore mentioned 5 point Calvinist, explained it to me this way. He has a girlfriend. When he decided he liked his girlfriend, he decided that he was going to get her no matter what it took. She had no clue. But he did whatever he could to woo her and eventually he won her. He decided before she even knew what was happening that he was going to have her, and he knew he would do whatever it took to get her. People in this persuasion would say, "No, God does not force his love on us. His love is inevitable."
- The fourth opinion is the hardy, the few, "Hard Determinism." (I think it's somewhat amusing that this camp lands Universalists and Calvinists in the same place.) Mark Driscoll explained it this way. He had a child that was running towards a highway once as he was unloading his car. When he noticed he turned around and snatched her literally from the jaws of death as a semi went speeding by. (I think he moved from his house shortly thereafter.) Driscoll says, yes he loves his daughter. And because he loves her, he forced his love on her and didn't let her run into the highway. Similarly, we choose Hell. But God in His infinite love reaches down to the elect and forces his love on them despite the fact that they choose Hell. In fact, the ones who don't get what they choose are Christians, because they don't get what they want, which is Hell. They would say "Yes, God does his force His love on us."
In the next blog I will try to go into my opinion on the question of Free Will. But for now, discuss, comment, elaborate what your opinions are on the topic? It' s a good philosophical question to see where you end up. Any "fifth" opinions are welcome.
Matt! Why didn't you tell me you write a blog. This is good! And it's just the kind of thing I need, because I can't debate religion or philosophy with anyone at NYU because I'm the only Christian :/
ReplyDeleteFirstly I'd like to say that "(I think it's somewhat amusing that this camp lands Universalists and Calvinists in the same place.)" is not necessarily accurate, in the sense that one is, in a sense, a cop out for hippies who can't accept responsibility, and the other more or less makes someone feel somewhat special and chosen.. I see what you're saying, but it's sort of a stretch.
Regarding Calvinism, I used to have the same view of it as you.. well, you're hard determinism perspective at any rate. However, I've recently thought that it's more of a selective selection of the elect, in a sense, for the fighting of the battle in which humans are the key players. What I mean is, the elect who are chosen since before time are those whom God has created for his specific purposes related to a specific mission. Those people will, inevitably, as in your wooing example, find God. Whether or not they play out their mission to it's fullest vs not doing all they should be doing, or sinning and having to repent, whatever, is essentially the amount of free will they have. For those who are not elect, it's essentially up to the elect to preach the message through whatever means they were designed, and in so doing reach the gentiles, because as Roman's 2:11 says, God does not show favoritism. While in context he is talking about Jews and Gentiles, I believe the same concept applies. As it then goes on to say, we will be judged for our actions. How could we be justly judged if we had no choice? I was going somewhere with this, but I lost my train of thought. The fire alarm went off.. oh well!
-Michael PonTell
Haha, good ol' Michael. I tried to keep my biases neutral when writing this for now, but I'll elaborate on that in the next blog. But something to keep in mind is "Has the potter no right over the clay, to make out of the same lump one vessel for honorable use and another for dishonorable use?" Romans 9:21 ESV
ReplyDeleteCool blog Matty, this is what I like to think about it... What brought the person who accepted Christ to that point of acceptance? Was that person smarter than those who have not accepted Christ, or more holy? We know that these are not true for all have sinned and fall short of the glory of God. I think that it is God who bring us to the point of acceptance. I like how one theologian said it, "I am free, God is free, God is more free than me." I think to argue against that is to argue against Gods sovereignty.
ReplyDeleteDeterminists: "You free-will people were pre-destined to believe that free-will exists."
ReplyDeleteLibertarians: "You determinists are simply choosing to ignore your free will so you don't have to take responsibility for your own actions."
Determinists: "Duh."
Compatibilism seems to be the most attractive option, uniting people as different as David Hume and St. Augustine.
ReplyDeleteIf God is truly sovereign and free, then it seems perfectly reasonable to say that he may choose not to act. In doing so, he hasn't abandoned his sovereignty so much as he has reinforced his omnipotence. (Free Will:1, Determinism:0)
Suppose you are standing on a bridge that collapses. You may want to not fall, but your course has already been determined by physical law. Your will is powerless in this instance. (Free Will:1, Determinism:1)
Now suppose that I knew that given the choice between ice cream and brownies, you will choose the brownies. My foreknowledge hasn't affected your freedom to choose the ice cream. (Free Will:2, Determinism:1)
But I didn't create you, therefore my design wasn't the foundation of my foreknowledge. If God created us and knows the future, then surely he is somehow responsible for our actions. (Free Will:2, Determinism:2)
Tough call. A possible way out is by calling into question the principle of alternate possibilities.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Frankfurt_counterexamples
In the context of God's word, however, Christ speaks of both in the same verse.
http://www.biblegateway.com/passage/?search=John+6%3A37&version=NASB
Doug
ReplyDeleteIn your last point, you made the case that God created us and knows the future, somehow making him responsible for our actions. I was under the same impression for a while, which truly annoyed me because it seemed that that would also make God responsible for original sin, and thus all sin after. What I realized while reading "Mere Christianity" though, by one of C.S. Lewis little snippets, is that God, being outside of time, is also outside of the same laws that govern us in the form of cause and effect. If all that is human time is something that God can look at and see as a whole, then there is no, he did this, then this. There is only it is.
-Michael PonTell