In my last blog, I extrapolated four opinions to the question, "Does God force His love?" In my opinion, the question itself boils down to the essential question of Free Will. In my last blog I also made the statement that I believe will exemplify this discussion. The statement is this, "...No man who is a result of Western Civilization wants to deny Free Will, but no man who is a Christian wants deny God's sovereignty."
There are a few reasons I hate dealing with this question:
1. The Bible never really deals with the question of whether or not we have free will. Nobody ever asks Jesus, Moses, Isaiah, or Paul if we have free will, and even if they did they didn't answer them.
2. The question of free will versus determinism, as we know it, originates in the Greek culture. The question of free will essentially originates outside of Christianity.
3. Something Greco in origin has divided Modern Protestantism into two camps, Arminianism and Calvinism. In other words it is a very divisive topic, with often times people so dogmatic on either side they won't stop to look at it from more than one point of view.
There are a few reasons that I feel this question has to be dealt with in no particular order:
1. Our entire system of government depends on the entire idea of Free Will. If we can't hold people accountable for their actions, Western Civilization will crumble. Some would even argue that the Democratic and Republican ideals are fundamentally at odds over this question.
2. The question deals with something that can change our opinions on something so important as our salvation in Jesus Christ.
3. This is something that divides Modern Protestantism, if not Christianity, if not Civilization. While it is divisive, it is important that if people are to hold an opinion on it, they at least verse themselves well in it and converse both sides of the spectrum.
However, I don't have enough space to give a good discussion of that here, and partially I did that last week. A good place to look at it is this, http://www.gotquestions.org. They usually provide good discussions, and . I have promised my opinion on Free Will for this blog, so here it is.
Because this topic is not particularly dealt with in the Bible but has Theological Implications, I think that a starting place has to be somewhere that IS in the Bible. Once we have a Theology, we may then apply this to the question of free will. The question then becomes, where?
I think a good place to start is somewhere in Romans. Why Romans? Because Romans is the only Biblical text written specifically to lay out the Christian Theology to Christians. Paul, the author, has the best credentials of the known NT writers. For a list of credentials, Paul gives himself, see Galatians 1-2, Philippians 3, and any of the beginnings of Paul's letters. Paul had such confidence as to stand up to the highly impulsive Peter and the men of James, brother of Jesus. Paul was also the only one of the Christian men to claim the apostleship of the Gentiles.
I won't overview or delve into all the doctrinal subtleties in the book of Romans especially on the question of predestination. But listen to my take on Romans.
In Romans I see a basic three-fold organization of the text in the light of this fact, God does all things to glorify Himself.
1. God glorifies Himself in the fact that He is righteous, while we are not. It is akin to if a light shines in the darkness, how much more then will it be light? (Romans 1-3)
2. God glorifies Himself in the fact that while He is righteous and we are not, He can still redeem us by nothing that we can do, or in other words through Sola Fide. (Romans 3-5)
3. God glorifies Himself in the fact that after He has negated the penalty of sin, He can empower us to live in Christian freedom, specifically freedom from sin. (Romans 5-16) (Yes, there are also many other subjects in the text that speak about the fate of the Jewish people and eternal security.)
We can now apply this to the question of Free Will.
As I delve into the Scriptures I find the story of Moses confusing. Here is a man that runs from God, but God pursues him. God chases him. God scares him. God doesn't let him escape. In fact, when Moses grudgingly goes along with God's plan, God almost kills him for not circumcising his son. In other words, only heartfelt commitment is enough for God. That sounds like God forcing His love on Moses to me. We jump a few chapters ahead, God hardens Pharaoh's heart. God sounds like a Calvinist so far. We jump a few more chapters forward and God offers Moses a chance to become his own nation after Israel rejects God through the golden calf. But God allows Moses to say no? In the choice between Free Will and Determinism, one might conclude God was schizophrenic. But He's God. So mankind jumps in all these little circles to try to put God in a box, to try to describe Him, to try to understand Him. I would submit, I would argue, I would bet that we have gone too far in our search for a unity in the text here along the lines of Calvinism and Arminianism.
I would offer a new solution along the lines of Romans. God does what He does to glorify Himself. As Romans 9:20-21 says, "But who are you, O man to answer back to God? Will what is molded say to its molder, "Why have you made me like this" Has the potter no power over the clay, to make out of the same lump one vessel for honorable use and another for dishonorable use?" ESV
In other words, God does what He wants, for the purpose of the Potter to the clay, that God will do whatever He pleases to glorify Himself.
The only solution I can arrive at based on the Bible, the literal interpretation of the Bible, is that God gives some a greater deal of freedom, at different times, than He gives others. I call this the Regulated Will. We don't have an ultimately Free Will. It can't be. Theology, Philosophy, Physics, and Genetics all argue no. I can't jump out of my window and fly, I just can't. God is sovereign. But God does give each person a unique allotment of freedom. He must, if we are to take the words of Exodus literally. And if He didn't, why would Paul, Peter, John, Jude, and James write their epistles telling Christians how and why to STOP SINNING, because if they didn't have any freedom in this regard, then why bother? I can only arrive at this conclusion: Freedom isn't a constant. There's more present in some Christian's lives than others, but in the end, it's not constant from one life to the next.
Here is my take:
Adam and Eve were the only absolutely free humans. But they sinned, throwing mankind into a completely depraved mindset. Not only did mankind get separated from God, they declared war on His authority, handing over their kingship of creation to the Prince of this world. But Jesus came, taking the wrath of God in our place. After He broke our chains (the elect), the Holy Spirit came, and through the miracle of Regeneration, we have been given a parcel of freedom in order which to fight off Satan.
I do not see Biblical support to say that God gives us choice in whether or not we have any choice in the matter salvation. So by the classification of my last blog, I would be a Hard Determinist. God forces His love in area of Salvation on the elect. One of the cool things about Moody is that I get to hear alot of testimonies. I get to hear a lot of people tell me about their lives, I meet a lot of broken people made whole. But the one common denominator is Providence. From the homeschooler to the highschool jock to the bouncer at night clubs to the professor who used to be a homosexual drug user diagnosed with HIV, Providence is the one constant in their story.
Practically speaking, however, it doesn't really matter how much freedom or how much of a free will you or I have. The practical matter is whether or not you will use it to glorify God. In the words of Marcus Aurelius, Roman philosopher and emperor, "It remains then for thee to understand among what kind of workmen thou placest thyself; for He who rules all things will certainly make a right use of thee..."
Very interesting. I would agree that free will is something of an extra- biblical concept. It is interesting to me that God says he will harden Pharaohs heart in Exodus (13?). When I pointed this out to your Grandfather he said, "You predestination types always want to use that example!". However I think you are a bit off on free will being a Greek thing. Oedipus gouges out his eyes because the Oracles prophecy comes true. Last I heard John Stuart Mill wasn't greek;)
ReplyDeleteTrue dad, but most would agree that the debate originates in Greek thought.
ReplyDelete