First off, it's a rare thing to see a masterpiece film that doesn't need excessive violence, nudity, sex, excessive drinking and swearing, etc. to make it a real intriguing film. Let's be honest, the thing is a piece of art like it is. The plot, for those of you who will read anyways, is that a mind thief, or extractor, is working to navigate his way back into the US while dealing with legal accusations. A client offers to get him home no problem in return for one last job. The catch is that it isn't an extraction job like he's used to, the job involves planting an idea rather than stealing it. The main character also must deal with the regrets that sent him into exile in the first place, because they get in the way of his job while endangering his friends. Success gives him the chance to see his kids again, failure involves going to jail the rest of his life.
The big question is, is it real at the end? Does Cobb (Leonardo Dicaprio) really end up saving his children or is it all a dream? This last week, the question of the topic has engaged the conversations in my life at church, work, and home. It has engaged relationships with my friends, coworkers, family, and waiters at Denny's. The basic question is, is he awake or dreaming at the end? There are a plethora of theories, but in my opinion the theories have to submit to three tests. They have to navigate through all the plot subtleties and clues, in other words they have to make sense with the evidence given. They have to make sense in terms of plot, in other words they have to have a good cause and it has to make sense in terms of storytelling. Finally, there has to be a takeaway or a message for the viewers.
The Prima Facie, or assumption, in debating terms is that we start out with is that Cobb is successful and that it is he does return home to see his children. Any theories that we must submit must meet these terms better than the Prima Facie argument. The viewer wants to believe that the Prima Facie argument is correct because of the implications of the takeaway, that the hero does in fact rise to the challenge. However the small subtleties of the film, the top not falling over at the end and the fact that the children did not change throughout the film, despite at least an implied year away from his children, raise questions about the Prima Facie.
So what is the alternative that meets all of those requirements? The litmus test the film gives is the totem. When a spinning top that Cobb carries with him falls over we "know" that is reality. However, if the spinning top Cobb carries with him does not fall over we know that it is a dream. The problem is, we don't see the top fall over for most of the film, so we don't know what is dream and what is reality. Some have raised the fact that there is no real litmus test for the audience, there is nothing in the film that lets us know exactly what is dream and what is not, especially if the top is just in the dream. This leads many to conclude the entire movie takes place in dream space.
Here is my theory. Cobb goes to look for someone who can give him powerful sedatives for the special job. In that time, Cobb undergoes the sedatives to test them, and presumably dies in his dream which would normally wake someone from a sleep. However, under sedatives, the dreamer just goes even deeper into his dream when killed. When Cobb undergoes the sedatives, Mr. Seito also undergoes sedatives to attempt to use inception on him. It fills all the gaps and subtleties provided by the movie's clues. However, that raises the question, why would Seito do that in order to make sense of the plot? There are numerous explanations, the one that I believe makes the most sense is that Seito partly used inception to prove to Cobb that inception was in fact, possible, and partly he did it out of his own curiousity. There were many things that went wrong; but somehow Cobb still was successful with inception. This would make sense because Cobb is now an investment for Seito, and this sort of heist has many moving pieces that Seito would want to make sure was possible. Meanwhile Cobb has his own issues that he has to work out, and if I was a gazillionaire businessman, I would like to make sure that my investment is stable and ready for the job. So is Cobb still successful? In a way yes. He finally makes the decision to confront himself and his memories in order to return to see his children, now he just has to do it for real. Finally, what is the takeaway? Well one is that we must always continue to test reality, to test what is real rather than we want to be real.
So what does that mean to us as Christians?
Ariadne (Ellen Page) knows Cobbs secrets. As the movie progresses more and more, she continues to learn more and more about Cobb. Finally at the culmination of the movie, Ariadne tells Cobb he's not guilty for his wife's suicide. Cobb counters with one fact. Inception is possible because he performed it on his wife, Molly. The idea that he planted, that her world wasn't real, eventually caused her to kill herself when she awoke from the dream because she didn't realize she was in reality rather than a dream. Cobb has blood on his hands, sure he is legally clean, but morally he is oh so guilty, and he knows it. Instead of making excuses for himself, Cobb knows he's guilty and dead wrong. If that's not a symbol of humanity's sin sickness, I don't know what is.
"Let no one deceive himself. If anyone among you thinks that he is wise in this age, let him become a fool that he may become wise."
1 Cor 3:18 ESV
"...because they exchanged the truth about God for a lie and worshiped and served the creature rather than the Creator..." Romans 1:25
And that brings me to my final comments. In order to escape the dream world, one must give up his life. One must confront that the dream is not real. The dream, the culmination of the dreamer's desires and subconscious, can never mimic reality. Cobb tells his subconscious' perception or projection of his wife Molly that she is not Molly, because he could never mimic her. He could never mimic all her perfections and imperfections, all her beauty. In other words, what we perceive as reality is subject to our wants and desires.
An old man is handing out sedatives to rich men and women in Mombasa so they can dream all day. Cobb says like he's in an epiphany, "They come here to be put to sleep."
But the old man with a smug, new agey grin replies, "No, they come to be woken up. Who are you to tell them differently?" They come here because they prefer their wants and desires to reality.
But what if it's not real? What if our wants and desires can never mimic what is real? What if our wants and desires can never mimic what is good?
Here is the parallel biblically:
"For whoever would save his life will lose it, but whoever loses his life for my sake will find it." Matthew 16:25 ESV
God came so we might have life and have it abundantly. He came because all our wants and desires could never mimic the life that God provides. It is high time we as humans we stopped exchanging the Creator for the created. Laying aside the wisdom of the world means laying aside the wisdom of ourselves. Often times that means using the Bible (or our totem) in order to tell what is good and true.
My question for you is this: How much of your life is directed at fulfilling your wants and desires rather than living the abundant life God created for us? Not necessarily because wants and desires are bad, but they are always a flimsy imitation of the real thing.
No comments:
Post a Comment